The Brisbane Broncos enter the 2027 NRL season facing one of their most consequential selection decisions in years, with the retirement of captain and halfback Adam Reynolds leaving coach Michael Maguire needing to fill not one but two critical roles at Red Hill. How that vacancy is resolved could ultimately determine whether Maguire himself remains at the club beyond 2027.
Brisbane's 2026 campaign was historically poor. The defending premiers won just three of their final 16 games, finishing 14th in what is understood to be the worst season recorded by a reigning NRL champion in the modern era. Injuries and reported unrest in the dressing room compounded the club's woes, making the off-season rebuild one of the most urgent in the Broncos' recent history.
The captaincy question: Carrigan leads the queue
Replacing Reynolds as skipper appears to be the more straightforward of the two challenges. Several names are in contention, including Mitch Barnett, Kotoni Staggs, Billy Walters and Ben Hunt, but Pat Carrigan is considered the front-runner ahead of his contract expiry in 2028.
Carrigan made his ambitions clear during Australia's World Cup camp. "It's a privilege to be captain of the Broncos, and if that opportunity was to come, I'd take it with both hands and lead the club forward," he said. "I've always prided myself on not changing and being true to who I am. Success is what you chase, but the hiccups and bumps are what make you a better person."
Reynolds, for his part, will not be leaving the club entirely. He is set to remain at Brisbane in a coaching capacity.
Pezet: The anointed successor chasing a fresh start
When Jonah Pezet signed with the Broncos in 2025, he was widely regarded as Reynolds' heir apparent. The 23-year-old had impressed during 18 appearances for Melbourne, winning 13 of those games, and carried significant expectations into his move. What followed was a difficult lay-over season with Parramatta, where hamstring and shoulder injuries restricted him to just seven first-grade matches.
Crucially, Pezet has returned to pre-season training in November for the first time in nearly five years, a milestone he views as a turning point. "It's been tough, the injury stuff that I've been through, but I'm in a good spot now," he said. "I haven't had any issues since round 12, I've seen a fair few people and got some new ideas on how to look after that better."
Pezet also pointed to Brisbane assistant coach Trent Barrett, a former 295-game halfback, as a major factor in his decision to move to Queensland. He described Barrett as a "special mind" and expressed confidence the squad retains premiership-calibre talent. "We still have a premiership outfit. This roster and club is built on success," Pezet said, noting the extended pre-season gives Brisbane four months of preparation before a game is played.
Duffy: The local challenger making his case
Tom Duffy announced himself as a genuine contender as early as round six of 2026, slotting a field goal against North Queensland and contributing two try assists in the same match. Despite Brisbane falling short that night, Duffy's composure and game management drew wide attention. He also converted all five of his goal-kicking attempts, offering a skill set the Broncos need to replace now that Reynolds has stepped away.
Having been moved between halfback, five-eighth and even hooker throughout his time at the club, Duffy is eager to settle into his preferred position at No. 7. "I just feel comfortable at the NRL level now," he said. "The evidence of what you did on the field gives you confidence to do it again. I enjoy playing seven."
What comes next
With a full pre-season ahead and genuine competition between Pezet and Duffy, Maguire has both the time and the talent to make a measured call. The decision carries significant weight: the halfback chosen will be expected to drag a Broncos side off the bottom of the ladder and restore a club that, only 12 months ago, was celebrating a premiership.

