Premier Chris Minns has abandoned sweeping underquoting reforms for New South Wales real estate agents just hours before they were due to take effect, in a last-minute reversal that has wasted millions of dollars in industry preparation and left property buyers with no new protections. The laws, described when they were announced roughly a year ago as among the largest reforms to the real estate sector in decades, were pulled after concerns were raised by agents in the Premier's own Kogarah electorate.

What the Scrapped NSW Underquoting Reforms Would Have Done

The legislation, passed in June, was designed to restore trust and transparency to a property market that research has consistently shown is rife with manipulated price guides. Key measures included a mandatory requirement to include price guides in all buyer marketing, with those guides based on three comparable sales. Penalty fines were also set to rise sharply, from $22,000 to $110,000 or three times an agent's commission, whichever was the greater amount.

The package was a direct response to extensive investigations that found almost half of all properties sold at auction across New South Wales go for more than 10 per cent above the advertised guide, earning Sydney the unwanted distinction of being the underquoting capital of Australia. More than 9,100 people responded to those investigations, reporting widespread and blatant underquoting across New South Wales and Victoria. The majority said they had spent significant time and money researching properties they ultimately could not afford.

The reforms did contain a clause that proved problematic: a restriction preventing agents from advertising a price below any written offer that had previously been rejected by the seller. In a rising market this causes no difficulty, but in a falling market it creates a genuine bind, as sellers cannot revise their price downward if they had earlier knocked back a higher written offer. The government had been warned of this unintended consequence multiple times before the legislation passed.

Minister Admits Laws Were "Not Fit for Purpose"

Better Regulation and Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong conceded on Monday night that the laws had been passed "at a different time and in a different economic and housing market," an acknowledgement that the legislation was no longer suited to current conditions. The admission came only hours before the reforms were scheduled to begin operating at midnight.

The only clear beneficiaries of the backflip, observers note, are the real estate agents who have long profited from underquoting. The practice has already claimed one high-profile scalp: former top-selling agent Josh Tesolin was handed a decade-long industry ban and fines of $33,000 after being found to have engaged in sustained unlawful, improper and dishonest conduct across more than 100 property transactions.

Industry Left Reeling After Months of Costly Preparation

Real estate companies and their agents had been preparing for the changes for months, investing heavily in compliance training across the state. Dan White, the head of Australia's largest real estate franchise Ray White Group, said the reversal had left members who had devoted considerable time, effort and energy to preparing for the new rules in a deeply difficult position.

"Over the past six months, our compliance team has run sessions with all 3,400 of our NSW members," White said. "We hired halls from Yamba to Orange to hold zone meetings across the state."

Ray White also built a dedicated real-time compliance platform called Stockboard, which scans residential listings across the group and flags any that do not meet underquoting requirements. The platform is already operating in Victoria, where separate reforms were rolled out in October requiring an advertised reserve price to be published a week before all auctions.

What Happens Now for Sydney Buyers

With no replacement legislation announced and no clear timeline for revised reforms, Sydney buyers heading to auctions in coming weeks will face the same environment they always have: price guides that may bear little resemblance to what a property actually sells for. The 11th-hour turnaround has not only erased months of industry work and significant compliance spending, it has done lasting damage to public confidence in the state government's ability to deliver meaningful legislative reform in the housing sector.