A children's mural at a Brisbane library produced using generative artificial intelligence has ignited a fierce debate about the role of AI in public art, with Australia's peak visual arts body calling on councils to introduce formal regulations after the work drew widespread condemnation.

The mural, installed as part of upgrades to the Bulimba Library in Brisbane, features nautical decorations and panels depicting the city's CBD in a kids' reading nook. Brisbane City Council has since confirmed the work was AI-generated and said it would be replaced once a local artist could be commissioned.

What is wrong with the Bulimba Library mural

Observers were quick to point out a series of tell-tale errors embedded in the imagery. The mural depicts a cockatoo with three wings and a seagull with a cockatoo's beak, while text on a CityCat ferry is illegible. Perhaps most strikingly, the layout of Brisbane's CBD does not reflect reality, with major landmarks appearing on the wrong side of the river.

Dr Simon Degroot, program director for the bachelor of visual arts at Griffith University's Queensland College of Art and Design, described the installation as "bland" and said it reminded him of AI-generated restaurant photos.

"It doesn't seem to be an artwork that would be a cultural addition to liven up a space, but rather a very one-dimensional prompt outcome," Degroot said. He added that a children's reading space was a particularly poor fit for a reminder of AI's growing presence in everyday life. "It's all about opening up creative minds and imagination," he said, noting the errors in the image made the AI origins impossible to ignore. "I think that's made more problematic in a children's reading space."

Degroot said this likely explained the intensity of the public reaction: "That probably is why it's such a hard, high backlash."

Peak arts body calls for AI regulation in public art commissions

Penelope Benton, executive director of the National Association for the Visual Arts (NAVA), said on Wednesday that human artists needed to be at the forefront of all public art projects and that she was disappointed by the Bulimba mural.

"Public art is work, and artists should be paid to do it. That shouldn't change because AI can generate an image in seconds," Benton said. "If a council can't afford to pay an artist, don't install a mural. You just don't need to do that."

Benton also rejected the argument that a temporary installation justified bypassing professional artists. "Temporary artworks can also be commissioned," she said.

She called for the use of AI in public art to be formally regulated and urged local governments to incorporate a NAVA framework, currently being drafted, into their art-commissioning policies.

Benton was careful to frame the concern as one of process and rights rather than an outright ban. "None of us are anti-AI, but there has to be an approach to this technology that considers human creativity and an artist's right to earn a living from their work," she said. "I wouldn't say that AI should be strictly forbidden, because artists are also experimenting."

What NAVA wants to see, she explained, is genuine artist involvement rather than administrators simply entering prompts into a system. "It would be an artist driving that process and feeding it in. It would just be respecting artists' copyright."

Council history and broader Brisbane debate

The irony of the controversy is not lost on those familiar with the site. The Bulimba Library stands on the former location of the Bulimba School of Arts, a heritage building constructed in 1887. The council took over the building in the 1960s, demolished it in 1982, and the library reopened in its current form in 1985.

The chair of the Brisbane City Council customer services committee, Jamboree Ward councillor Sarah Hutton, highlighted the site's arts history at a council meeting on 3 November. She pointed to a courtyard mural by artist Ryan Barwick, inspired by the history of Bulimba, as an example of meaningful local artistic engagement. Hutton also posted online about a mural located downstairs in the library.

The debate has extended beyond the Bulimba installation. At the same council meeting, Labor opposition leader Jared Cassidy criticised the council's decision to sanction AI use in its Brisbane Portrait Prize, suggesting the controversy over AI-generated imagery is becoming a broader point of contention within Brisbane's civic arts community.

What happens next

Brisbane City Council has indicated the AI-generated mural will be replaced once a local artist is available to be commissioned, though no timeline has been provided. NAVA's framework for AI use in public art is still being drafted, meaning any formal guidance for councils remains some time away.

The episode underscores a tension playing out across the creative industries as generative AI tools become faster and cheaper, raising urgent questions about whether cost-cutting at the expense of professional artists is acceptable, particularly in publicly funded spaces intended to celebrate culture and inspire imagination. For a children's library built on a site with more than a century of arts history, critics argue the answer is clearly no.